If you’re considering a move to Indianapolis and are curious about the Best Areas to Live on the North Side of Indianapolis, you’re not alone. Many people initially think of Carmel, Fishers, or Zionsville as the primary northern hotspots, but the north side of Indianapolis itself is much larger and offers a surprising variety of neighborhoods, commercial hubs, and lifestyle options. From bustling shopping centers to peaceful residential areas, the north side has something for everyone.
In this detailed guide, we’ll explore the key areas on the north side of Indianapolis, including Traders Point, Keystone, Nora, and Castleton. You’ll get an insider’s look at what each area offers—from shopping and dining to housing options and community vibes. Whether you want high-end amenities, affordable living, or convenient access to downtown and surrounding suburbs, this guide will help you pinpoint the perfect northside neighborhood for your needs.
Let’s dive in and uncover why the north side of Indianapolis is often underestimated and why it might just be the best place for your next home.
Table of Contents
- Understanding the Geography of the North Side of Indianapolis
- Traders Point: The Western Gateway
- Keystone: The Heart of Northside Commercial Life
- Nora: A Charming Residential Neighborhood
- Castleton: The Eastern Edge of Northside Living
- Shopping and Dining Highlights on the North Side
- Residential Options: Affordable to Upscale
- Transportation and Accessibility
- Why Choose the North Side of Indianapolis?
- FAQs About Living on the North Side of Indianapolis
- Conclusion
Understanding the Geography of the North Side of Indianapolis
The north side of Indianapolis is a vast and diverse area that extends from the far western edge near 465 and 86th Street all the way east past Allisonville Road into Castleton. One of the key features of this region is its numbered streets system—the higher the street number, the further north you are. For instance, 38th Street or 10th Street places you deep within Indianapolis, while 96th Street marks the general northern border of the city before you reach suburbs like Fishers, Carmel, or Zionsville.
This stretch includes several major neighborhoods and commercial districts that collectively create a vibrant and convenient living environment. The primary areas include:
- Traders Point – Located at the far west near 465 and 86th Street.
- Nora – Nestled between Traders Point and Keystone, known for a more residential feel.
- Keystone – A bustling commercial and retail hub with upscale shopping.
- Castleton – The easternmost part on the north side, featuring shopping and dining.
Traveling along 86th Street (which shifts to 82nd Street as it moves eastward) will take you through all these neighborhoods without much interruption, making it a continuous corridor of commercial and residential activity.
Traders Point: The Western Gateway
At the far west end near the intersection of 465 and 86th Street lies the Traders Point area, often considered the western gateway to the north side of Indianapolis. While this area wasn’t the focus of our current exploration, it’s worth noting that Traders Point offers a mix of residential neighborhoods and commercial developments. It’s a more suburban feel with easy highway access, making it a convenient spot for commuters or those wanting a quieter lifestyle on the outskirts of the city.
For those interested in exploring Traders Point further, it’s a great place to find larger lots, new construction homes, and proximity to natural areas, including parks and trails.
Keystone: The Heart of Northside Commercial Life
Moving east from Traders Point, you arrive at Keystone, one of the most prominent and vibrant commercial districts on the north side. Keystone is home to the Keystone Fashion Mall, a major shopping destination featuring a wide variety of stores and restaurants. This area caters to shoppers looking for everything from everyday essentials to high-end luxury items.
One standout feature of Keystone is the presence of Saks Fifth Avenue, a luxury department store that offers upscale clothing, shoes, and accessories. While not everyone shops there regularly, it’s a clear sign of the upscale retail options available in the area.
Besides Saks Fifth Avenue, Keystone boasts a broad mix of retail shops, including popular brands like Vuori, which is known for its activewear and outdoor apparel. Many residents enjoy the convenience of shopping in-store or online with this brand.
Keystone’s commercial landscape is complemented by numerous restaurants and eateries, making it a hotspot not just for shopping but also for dining and socializing. The area is perfect for residents who want to live close to amenities and entertainment without venturing far from home.
Nora: A Charming Residential Neighborhood
Between Traders Point and Keystone lies Nora, a smaller but beloved neighborhood that offers a more residential atmosphere. Nora has a unique charm that many long-time residents appreciate, including myself. When I first moved to Indianapolis in the 1990s, I ended up in Nora quite by accident, but it quickly became a favorite area.
Nora is notable for its mature trees, quiet streets, and a sense of community that’s hard to find in busier commercial areas. It’s an excellent choice if you want to be close to shopping and dining but still enjoy a peaceful neighborhood feel.
Despite its residential nature, Nora has convenient access to several commercial amenities. For example, there’s a Target store, a United States Post Office, and a large Kroger grocery store nearby. The Monon Trail, a popular biking and walking trail, also runs close by, offering easy access to outdoor activities and a route to downtown Indianapolis.
One of the reasons Nora stands out is because it offers a mix of housing options. You can find affordable apartments, older homes built in the 1950s, 60s, and 70s, and well-established neighborhoods with mature landscaping. While new construction is limited here, the mature homes and tree-lined streets provide a welcoming, lived-in feel.
Castleton: The Eastern Edge of Northside Living
Traveling further east past Allisonville Road, you enter Castleton, another major commercial and residential area on the north side of Indianapolis. Castleton is known for its large shopping centers, including another Trader Joe’s location, which is a favorite among locals for specialty groceries and unique food items.
Castleton offers a wide mix of retail shops, restaurants, and services. This area tends to be busier and more commercial, making it ideal for those who want quick access to a broad range of amenities. It’s also a great location for visitors or residents who want to stay in a central spot while exploring Indianapolis and the surrounding suburbs like Carmel, Fishers, and Zionsville.
One of the highlights of Castleton is the Ironworks Hotel, a stylish and upscale lodging option. Though it’s not a budget hotel, it offers excellent accommodations and is surrounded by numerous dining options, including sushi spots, breakfast places, and breweries. This area is especially convenient for those who want to enjoy the north side’s culinary scene and nightlife.
Shopping and Dining Highlights on the North Side
The north side of Indianapolis excels in offering a diverse range of shopping and dining experiences across its neighborhoods. Here are some of the key highlights:
- Whole Foods Market in Nora: This centrally located Whole Foods is a popular destination for residents from both Indianapolis and nearby Carmel. It’s known for its quality organic and specialty foods, and while it can get busy, it’s a reliable spot for fresh groceries.
- Trader Joe’s: There are two Trader Joe’s on the north side—one near Keystone and another in Castleton. These stores are favorites for their unique products, affordable prices, and friendly atmosphere.
- Keystone Fashion Mall: Beyond Saks Fifth Avenue, the mall hosts a variety of shops and restaurants, making it a one-stop destination for shopping and dining.
- Restaurants near Ironworks Hotel: Provision, Blue Sushi Sake Grill , Rise, Yolk, Poke Brothers, and Daredevil Brewery are just a few of the notable eateries and breweries in this area, offering everything from sushi to breakfast to craft beer.
These shopping and dining options not only add convenience but also enhance the quality of life for north side residents, making it easy to enjoy a vibrant lifestyle without traveling far.
Residential Options: Affordable to Upscale
One of the biggest advantages of living on the north side of Indianapolis is the wide range of residential options available. Whether you’re looking for something affordable, a family-friendly neighborhood, or upscale living, the north side has it all.
Here’s a breakdown of the residential landscape:
- Older Homes: Many neighborhoods on the north side feature homes built in the 1950s, 60s, 70s, and 80s. These homes often come with mature trees and established landscaping, offering a cozy and welcoming environment.
- New Construction: While newer homes are less common in some parts of the north side, areas south of 86th and 82nd Streets toward Broad Ripple and Meridian-Kessler have seen some recent developments.
- Apartment and Condo Living: Areas like Nora and Castleton have apartment complexes and condos that cater to singles, young professionals, and smaller households looking for convenience and community amenities.
- Luxury Options: For those seeking upscale living, neighborhoods near Keystone and Traders Point offer luxury homes, gated communities, and high-end amenities.
This diversity means you’re not limited to one type of housing or price point, which is a huge plus if you want flexibility in your home search.
Transportation and Accessibility
The north side of Indianapolis benefits from excellent transportation links. Interstate 465 runs near many of these neighborhoods, making it easy to commute downtown or to other parts of the metro area. Keystone Avenue and 82nd/86th Streets are major east-west corridors that connect the various neighborhoods and commercial districts.
Public transportation options are limited but improving, and the Monon Trail provides a fantastic alternative for cyclists and pedestrians who want to enjoy the outdoors while commuting or exercising.
The proximity to major highways and well-maintained roads means north side residents can enjoy suburban tranquility without sacrificing easy access to city amenities and employment centers.
Why Choose the North Side of Indianapolis?
Many people overlook the north side of Indianapolis when considering where to live, focusing instead on suburbs like Carmel or Fishers. However, the north side offers a unique blend of urban convenience, suburban comfort, and diverse lifestyle options that make it a fantastic choice for many.
Here are some reasons why the north side stands out:
- Variety of Neighborhoods: From quiet, tree-lined streets in Nora to bustling commercial hubs in Keystone and Castleton, there’s a neighborhood to fit every preference and budget.
- Access to Amenities: Shopping, dining, entertainment, and grocery options abound, often within walking distance or a short drive.
- Convenient Location: Easy access to highways and major roads means commuting and weekend getaways are hassle-free.
- Community and Lifestyle: Whether you want a family-friendly neighborhood, a vibrant social scene, or peaceful living, the north side accommodates all lifestyles.
In short, the north side of Indianapolis is a hidden gem that deserves more attention from homebuyers and renters alike.
FAQs About Living on the North Side of Indianapolis
What are the main neighborhoods on the north side of Indianapolis?
The primary neighborhoods include Traders Point, Nora, Keystone, and Castleton. Each offers different vibes, from suburban tranquility to bustling commercial areas.
Is the north side more affordable than Carmel or Fishers?
Generally, yes. The north side offers a wider range of housing prices, including more affordable options compared to Carmel or Fishers, which tend to be more upscale and expensive.
Are there good shopping and dining options on the north side?
Absolutely. Keystone and Castleton are major commercial hubs with malls, restaurants, grocery stores like Whole Foods and Trader Joe’s, and many other amenities.
How is the transportation on the north side?
The area is well-connected by major roads and highways like Interstate 465, Keystone Avenue, and 82nd/86th Streets. The Monon Trail also offers recreational and commuting options for cyclists and pedestrians.
What types of housing are available?
There is a wide variety, including older homes with mature landscaping, newer construction, apartments, condos, and luxury homes, catering to diverse budgets and preferences.
Is it family-friendly?
Yes, many neighborhoods on the north side are highly family-friendly with parks, good schools, and community amenities.
Where can I find Whole Foods and Trader Joe’s on the north side?
Whole Foods is centrally located in Nora, while there are two Trader Joe’s—one near Keystone and another in Castleton.
Conclusion
The north side of Indianapolis offers an impressive array of living options, from the upscale shopping and dining of Keystone to the cozy residential streets of Nora, and the bustling retail centers of Castleton. It’s a region that’s often underestimated but truly has more to offer than most people realize.
Whether you’re looking for affordable housing, luxury amenities, or simply a convenient location with plenty of options for entertainment and everyday living, the north side of Indianapolis is a fantastic place to explore. Its diverse neighborhoods, strong community feel, and excellent access to highways and trails make it a top choice for anyone considering a move to the Indianapolis metro area.
If you’re thinking about making the north side your home, don’t hesitate to reach out with questions about the area or the home buying process. There’s a lot to love here, and with the right guidance, you can find the perfect spot to call home. If you're ready to take the next step, feel free to call or text me at 317-932-8620 !
