Is all of Carmel IN nice?

Upswingnow • June 28, 2023

Is all of Carmel IN nice?

If you live in Indiana, and maybe even if you do not, you perhaps already have a sense for the reputation that Carmel, Indiana has. This popular Indianapolis suburb is well known for its fantastic school system, beautiful infrastructure, and yes…very expensive housing. But could you afford to live in Carmel, Indiana, if you don’t happen to have a massive salary? It might not be easy, but you may be able to make it work!

Carmel is a not-so-small town

With over 100,000 people calling Carmel home, it is one of Indianapolis’ largest suburbs. Indianapolis itself boasts a population of 900,000, so Carmel is still much smaller than the city, but it isn’t sleepy by any means. With 100K residents, there are plenty of people making it work in Carmel, and you have to imagine not all of them are millionaires.

Carmel is a very safe place to live

Unfortunately, Indianapolis gets a pretty bad reputation when it comes to safety. Mostly due to its sheer size, the crime rates in Indy are fairly high. Most of the crime is isolated to certain parts of town. Like any place, there are good neighborhoods, and less-than-savory neighborhoods.

In Carmel , you will be hard pressed to find any of these not-so-great areas. All of Carmel is extremely safe, and even the more affordable parts of town are not crime-stricken. Of the crime that does take place in Carmel, it is almost all non-violent crime, such as vandalism and theft. While no one wants to see their things getting damaged or stolen, in comparison to the violent crime we see more of in the city of Indy, it’s much safer.

Westfield IN neighborhood, How far north is too far for Indianapolis

Most affordable parts of Carmel

So, while we have agreed that all of Carmel is aesthetic and safe, are there any parts of town where you can hope to find a more affordable home? Yes, there are! First things first, you can eliminate looking near the Arts and Design district, and downtown, as these are some of the newest, most contemporary, and yes, expensive parts of town.

East Carmel is the oldest part of town (not extremely old, because once you get into the historic homes near downtown, they are of course expensive due to high demand and their location.) The homes in east Carmel are mostly built in the late 20 th century, and many of these houses have original 1980’s infrastructure that has not been updated.

Keep in mind that while the most affordable homes in Carmel might be cheaper by Carmel standards, you will still get less for your dollar if you decide to call Carmel home than if you lived in one of the other popular Indianapolis suburbs. But if living in lovely, safe Carmel is your goal, it can be done!

Carmel Indiana, How far north is too far for Indianapolis

Are you thinking of moving to Carmel, Indiana, or anywhere else in the Indianapolis Metro Area? If so, reach out to me at Compton Realty. I would love to help you find your perfect home in beautiful Indianapolis.

jason compton

A  former teacher turned full-time real estate agent serving Greater Indianapolis. I help buyers, sellers, and relocation clients make informed moves—especially those coming from out of state. From neighborhood insights to home tours, my goal is to simplify the process and help you feel confident in every step.

ready to move?

A man is standing in front of a city skyline on the cover of a relocation guide for indianapolis.

WATCH OUR VIDEOS

Stay Informed

Insights, Tips & Life in Indianapolis

Your go-to resource for all things real estate and Indy living. Whether you're buying, selling, relocating, or just curious about the local market, our blog is packed with helpful articles, expert advice, and community highlights to keep you informed and inspired.

Man in red shirt smiling, next to city skyline. Text
By Jason Compton November 7, 2025
Explore the unexpected charms of living in Indianapolis — hidden parks, reclaimed ruins, Tomlinson Hall catacombs, the Cultural Trail, brunch culture, and affordable local rituals.
Man in red shirt smiling in front of a modern circular building and Indianapolis cityscape.
By Jason Compton October 31, 2025
Discover how 16 Tech, the Indianapolis airport aerotropolis, and the IU Health academic center — billion-dollar projects — will reshape housing, commercial and industrial markets.
Man pointing at a city skyline; video title:
By Jason Compton October 28, 2025
Only have a long weekend to evaluate living in Indianapolis? Follow a focused 3-day plan to sample neighborhoods, parks, and amenities—and leave with a clear sense of the metro.
Man interviewing another man outdoors; title
By Jason Compton October 22, 2025
An honest local’s guide to moving to Indianapolis — big-city perks without the headaches, food and music scenes, Midwest hospitality, and what to know about visible homelessness.
Man pointing at Indianapolis highlighted in red on a map, text
By Jason Compton October 21, 2025
Man gesturing towards a red map with yellow arrows indicating movement, title
By Jason Compton October 17, 2025
Considering a move to Indianapolis? Jason Compton breaks down where buyers are coming from, top neighborhoods (Carmel, Zionsville, Fishers, Noblesville), prices, and lifestyle trade-offs.
Man in suit with sad expression in front of city skyline with the words
By Jason Compton October 13, 2025
Thinking of moving to Indianapolis? A local breaks down what Indy and its suburbs actually offer—needs vs wants, neighborhood personality, and next steps.
A man in a white shirt looks concerned, with a rundown neighborhood on the left and a nice one on the right.
By Jason Compton October 9, 2025
Find the best Indianapolis neighborhoods without HOAs. Ranked D→A with price ranges, pros/cons, hidden costs and buyer tips to help you choose the right HOA-free area.
Aerial view of suburban Whiteland, Indiana with houses and trees.
By Jason Compton October 7, 2025
Considering a move to Whiteland, IN? Local guide on history, housing, commute, schools, parks and affordability — practical tips and a moving checklist for newcomers.
Man pointing to map with
By Jason Compton October 3, 2025
Street-level breakdown of five Indianapolis suburbs where demand is softening. Learn which micro-markets (like Westfield and McCordsville) give buyers leverage and what sellers should do.
Show More