5 Small Towns Near Indianapolis Worth Moving To
There are actually a lot of small towns sitting within an hour of downtown Indianapolis, and there's about five of them that come up in almost every relocation conversation my team and I have. So why does nobody ever talk about the rest? Because when you're moving here, you're mostly seeing whatever shows up on the first page of Google, and that first page is basically the same five suburbs over and over.
We've spent years in the smaller markets past that first page. So these picks come out of actual deals and not just a generic search result. I'm Jason Compton. My team and I help people buy, sell, and relocate all around Indianapolis, and a lot of our clients come here from far away, from California, or even nearby like Chicago and the East Coast, looking exactly for what we're covering.
These are the towns that relocation guides around here usually skip over. We're going to get into the price, the feel, the schools, and who's moving there. And my honest pick for really the top one on this list.
Table of Contents
- Danville: Historic Charm 25 Minutes West of Downtown
- Bargersville: Growing Without Losing What It Was
- New Palestine: The Clearest Friday Night Town in the Metro
- Fortville: Quaint Setting with Convenient Metro Access
- McCordsville: Affordable Access to Geist and Fort Benjamin Harrison
- Which Small Town Is Right for You?
- Conclusion
Danville: Historic Charm 25 Minutes West of Downtown
Drive about 25 minutes straight west out of downtown Indianapolis and the road's going to eventually narrow down. You're going to have subdivisions and basically everything else just kind of start to thin out. And you're going to come up on a courthouse square with shops all the way around it and some real small town charm. That's Danville, Indiana.
Danville is out here kind of away from things a little bit, but it's an important town. It's actually the county seat in Hendricks County, just to the west of Indianapolis. That's where you're going to find some of the other towns that a lot of people know, Brownsburg, Avon, and Plainfield. Most people relocating here never type Danville into any search bar because the west side of Indianapolis gets skipped a lot. We really see a lot of people with their eyes pointing towards those suburbs on the north side of Indianapolis.
But Danville has something a lot of the bigger suburbs gave up a long time ago. It has a real historic downtown. It's not a downtown that somebody built in 2019 and then just named it a town center. It's an actual old square with the courthouse sitting right in the middle of it. Other than the courthouse itself, you're going to have local restaurants, really good restaurants, and a coffee shop, hardware store. You're going to have the Mayberry Cafe. And you're going to have a lot of people out here walking through the week or especially on the weekends, on really nice weekends.
Who's Moving to Danville
For the most part, the people moving out here are probably going to be either remote workers or they're working on the west side of Indianapolis. Or out near the airport, which is roughly just about 20 minutes away. A lot of people have been surprised by that proximity. And it's also people moving to a place like Danville that want a little bit of land or a little bit of space without driving out in the middle of nowhere an hour away to get it.
You'll see a mix of older homes that are closer into this square, and of course you're going to have newer construction because Danville has been growing for a number of years now, but that's going to push out towards the edges of town. And your money, generally speaking, is going to go a bit further here than it does, especially on the north side of the metro. But that's the trade you're making. You're further from places like Carmel and Fishers and that whole scene, or even downtown Indianapolis or some of the popular spots in Indianapolis, like along Mass Ave. But you're paying less for the same square footage. And that is sometimes more important to people.
Schools and Connectivity
The schools are all under Danville Community School Corporation, which is a single small district rather than one of the giant systems that you're going to have up north. And that scale definitely matters to some people. And of course it doesn't matter at all to other people.
The thing that people usually get wrong about Danville is that they assume the west side means it's going to be far from everything, and it's absolutely not. You've got I-70 and I-74 both within really just a few minutes of here, and Avon and Plainfield are right there if you need to have a Target run or just your big box shopping. So you're going to get the small town square and the small town vibe without actually being isolated truly from anything.
Bargersville: Growing Without Losing What It Was
A lot of people moving here look at the south side of Indianapolis and they see just really one place. They see Greenwood. But if you keep going southwest past the shopping that it has, some of the traffic honestly that goes along with it on US 31 especially, you get to Bargersville , and it's going to be a very different feel compared to just 10 minutes earlier going through Greenwood.
Bargersville is in Johnson County, and it's probably the best example around Indy of a town that's growing without losing what it was. You still got the downtown strip, not exactly gigantic at all, but there is a little bit of stuff here on this strip. Got Taxman Brewery, which is one of my favorites, actually. The food there is amazing. You've got other restaurants along here too. You've got a little tiny place, I wouldn't call it quite an amphitheater, but a little place where they have outdoor festivals and music. And then you've got newer subdivisions and homes on some slightly bigger lots going up around the edges of all of this here.
Who's Buying in Bargersville
The people buying out here, generally they want more space. A decent number of people who end up here work downtown, and they're okay with a 30-minute shot up I-65 or maybe US-31. And your budget stretches out here too. You can definitely get a yard, you can get a garage that fits more than your car. Maybe you can put your kids' bikes in there and some other toys and things like that, really under what the same house costs in those northern, more expensive suburbs.
If you're not sure what your actual number is just yet, the best first step for sure is figuring that out. You can reach out to a lender, or you can reach out to the lender that we've worked with for a lot of years. We've worked with Mac Howell at First Community Mortgage for more than 10 years for so many reasons. His team and Mac are phenomenal. His contact information is below, but that's always the first best step before you certainly fall in love with a house or even decide on which town is going to be the best fit for you.
The School District Lines Aren't Clean
Here's the thing that I'd flag on Bargersville though: the school district lines around Bargersville are not clean. If schools are a part of why you're moving, you can't assume that the town name tells you everything and tells you the district. You can have a Bargersville address and you can be in Center Grove Schools, or you can be in Franklin Community Schools. Even though Franklin is not terribly far away, it seems like it would be far enough away that you wouldn't have to worry about any address in Bargersville being in Franklin schools.
My team and I check that address by address every single time because we've absolutely seen people fall in love with a house only then just to discover a little bit later that it's not an option for them because it's not in the school district they wanted to be in.
Bargersville vs. Greenwood
One misconception that we hear quite a bit is that Bargersville is just really similar to Greenwood. It's basically just a different address you're going to be writing on the envelope, and it isn't at all. Greenwood has really grown a lot, and it's really a full commercial corridor. So you can find about every single thing that you can find across the country. And of course, that's going to come along with some of the congestion and the traffic that usually comes with those things. And Bargersville still functions like its own town with its own pace, even as the new rooftops and the growth is happening all around it. And that distinction is exactly why it keeps showing up on our buyer shortlists once they actually drive both of those places, Greenwood and Bargersville, back to back.
New Palestine: The Clearest Friday Night Town in the Metro
About 25 minutes or so just east of downtown Indianapolis, just off US 52, you'll find Main Street through the town of New Palestine . New Palestine might be the clearest example of a Friday night town anywhere in the metro. And what I mean by that is pretty much the whole town shows up to the high school football game. And New Palestine is kind of that school that you see their name everywhere. They're the school that's just kind of good at everything.
New Palestine sits in Hancock County. It's served by New Palestine Community Schools, and it is genuinely small. It's not been absorbed into Indianapolis like a lot of other smaller towns have been. A lot of people buying out here work on the east side or downtown, and they want a really relatively quick, very boring commute on I-70 instead of fighting traffic. And a lot of it is people coming from somewhere just much larger and they want something smaller. They want a town that's smaller. They want a school system where the administration and all the teachers in the school know their kids' names.
Housing and Value
You'll find a mix of older homes in kind of the core of New Palestine itself. Really old homes, we're talking about homes that are 30 years and 20 years old. But when we're talking about new construction, you can find a lot of newer construction neighborhoods around New Palestine. Of course, they still have that town name and they're expanding out into what used to be but still remains a lot of farm ground. And generally speaking, your dollar goes further here than it does in a lot of places, especially on the north side in the northern suburbs. Which is one of the reasons it's on this list.
Why Roads Matter Out Here
Towns like New Palestine live and die on which side of a county road you're on. Roads out here change districts, they change trash service, they change what your commute actually looks like at 7:40 in the morning versus what a map is going to say. And my team and I specialize in long distance and out-of-state buyers. These are people that have to make smart decisions remotely or just in one short visit. And this is precisely the stuff that can wreck those trips.
There's also a misconception that a small school system like New Palestine means fewer options once your kids get older. But in practice, it usually means the opposite of that. And it's a big problem that people have a lot of times in really large schools, you do have a lot of opportunity and a lot of variety, but sometimes your opportunity is taken away because it can be relatively competitive.
Fortville: Quaint Setting with Convenient Metro Access
There's a downtown about 30 minutes northeast of Indianapolis where the buildings are old, they've been around a long time, and the streets around it are lined with trees. That's Fortville . And it's one of the few small town gems left on that side of the Indy Metro.
It sits right off US 36, and you're just minutes from Fishers. In fact, you share a border with Fishers there and McCordsville nearby. So you're getting a really quaint setting with super convenient access to everything that the metro has around it, and that combination is a big reason why people move here.
Why Fortville Reads Differently
Why does Fortville read differently than a newer suburb? Well, the main reason is because it wasn't built all at once. It's actually been here a very, very long time. It's just been revitalized recently in the past 20 or so years. This downtown area is really super unique. It's got boutique shops, it has really good restaurants, and it has seasonal events that the town and other people around actually turn out for.
And then the housing runs from some really cool historic homes around this main street and older cottages that you'll find within walking distance of here on some of those tree-lined streets, those really mature streets. And it goes all the way into newer developments and newer neighborhoods, newer construction on the edges. But the edges aren't that far away, so you can really buy two completely different lifestyles inside the same town limits.
Who's Buying in Fortville
The people we see buying in Fortville are usually ones who tried the big new construction neighborhoods first and realized they wanted something with just a little bit more charm to it, a little more character to it. Somebody working in Fishers who doesn't want to live in Fishers. Maybe somebody coming from an older East Coast town who just walks into a brand new subdivision and just doesn't feel anything.
So Fortville can actually help solve that problem for some people because the town already has 100 years of history sitting right here in this downtown area. So whether you buy an old home or a brand new house nearby that is really just on the edge of it.
Why Local Knowledge Matters
This is where having somebody local really does matter more than people think when they're doing this from 1,000 miles away. My team and I help people buy, sell, and relocate all around the Indianapolis metro. And towns like Fortville almost never show up in an out-of-state buyer's research because they don't rank on the big relocation sites.
McCordsville: Affordable Access to Geist and Fort Benjamin Harrison
25 years ago, this town had just over 1,000 people in it, but today it's over 11,000, and that's McCordsville, Indiana . And it almost didn't make this list actually, because a town growing that fast usually loses exactly what put it on a list like this in the first place.
For the location, McCordsville sits on the northeast side of Indianapolis, and it's actually sharing a border with Indianapolis. So it's really not that far from Indianapolis itself. It's close to southeastern Fishers, which is actually just off to the north, a couple minutes from here, not that far at all. It shares some of the Geist District along with Geist Reservoir. It's near Fortville, which is just off to the east down the road. And it's really not all that far from areas that transition into Greenfield.
How McCordsville Got Pulled Along
The location there for McCordsville is a big part of the story because Fishers has expanded really hard in this direction out to the east and to the south. And Indianapolis pushes right up against it too, just off to the west over here. So McCordsville has been pulled along by all that growth without becoming those things.
Price and Schools
For price, compared with some of the nearby cities and towns, McCordsville can be really a more affordable way to get into newer housing. Carmel is definitely more expensive. Zionsville is more expensive. Westfield's generally more expensive. Fishers is oftentimes more expensive too, and on average it really is. And out here you can find a lot of homes under $500,000 and even some under $400,000 still. And that would include some homes that aren't ancient, they're still relatively new.
The schools piece is where a lot of people moving in from out of state really pay a lot of attention. McCordsville is generally served by Mount Vernon Schools. Most of those schools are kind of surrounding me from where I'm standing right now, but the high school is just off to the north. And Fishers, by comparison, has very large high schools. You've got Hamilton Southeastern High School and Fishers High School itself, and both of them are around the 3,400-student mark. And if you compare that to Mount Vernon High School, it's much smaller. It's right around 1,500 students, and that's a big difference in scale. And it's one of the first things people ask my team and myself because a lot of people here, or at least that are moving here, have never pictured a high school with 3,400 kids in it. And honestly, when you're talking about the north side schools, that's about as small as it gets.
The Nearby Water and Recreation
Then there's the nearby water, which honestly might be the most underrated thing about McCordsville. McCordsville is close to Geist Reservoir, and that can actually add a lot for some people. And you can't really forget at all about Fort Benjamin Harrison State Park, which is right next door. It's an unbelievably cool state park, so it can really be a super active recreational area, and you're not paying Geist Waterfront prices to be 10 minutes or less from all of it.
Building Its Own Identity
The town's also building its own identity right now with the planned, and actually a lot of it's completed, although there's more to go, McCord Square, this whole development. There's a goal to create a whole lot more to this. You're going to have more of a center, you're going to have an amphitheater, you're going to have more businesses and a little stronger sense of what McCordsville, the town, actually is.
One neighborhood that I especially like is nearby Ventner's Park, just off to the northwest. It's tucked away near 86th Street. It sits really close to a really unique place in McCordsville, Daniel's Vineyard, and that gives it a really interesting little bonus that you're not going to get in just a standard subdivision.
The Most Asked-About Town on the East Side
This is the town that we get asked about probably more than almost anywhere else on the east side of the metro. And it's the one that my team and I have spent the most time driving street by street, even as streets are added to McCordsville. So if you want the honest breakdown of just which pocket of McCordsville fits you, that's a conversation my team and I can have all day long.
A town that went from 1,000 people or less to almost 11,000 changes very fast. And the version that you see in a listing or in listing photos, and maybe on a Saturday afternoon when you're driving through, is not necessarily the version that you're going to live in day to day.
Which Small Town Is Right for You?
So then the real question is, which one of these towns fits you specifically? Because Indianapolis really gets massive when you're looking at it from out of state, and when you're here, it's usually bigger than what people realize. And the misconception that trips people up the most is assuming all these small towns are interchangeable, or they're the same, that if you like one, you're going to like all of them. And you won't. Danville and New Palestine are both really small towns, 25 minutes from downtown, and they feel really nothing alike once you're standing on the street. Pick the wrong one from 1,000 miles away and you're the family that could be listing again in two years.
Choose Danville if you want a real historic square, you're working on the west side or near the airport, and you want land or space without driving an hour out. You're trading proximity to Carmel and Mass Ave for a lower price and a slower pace.
Choose Bargersville if you want more space and bigger lots on the south side without the commercial corridor feel of Greenwood. Your budget stretches further here, but you must check school district lines address by address, you could be in Center Grove or Franklin schools with the same town name.
Choose New Palestine if you want a genuinely small school system where staff know your kids' names, a Friday night football town, and a boring commute on I-70. It's for people coming from somewhere larger who want something smaller, not people looking for variety and competition in a big district.
Choose Fortville if you want charm and character, mature tree-lined streets, historic homes, boutique shops, without giving up convenient access to Fishers and the metro. You can buy an old cottage near Main Street or new construction on the edges and still be in the same small town.
Choose McCordsville if you want a smaller high school than Fishers (1,500 vs. 3,400), affordable access to Geist Reservoir and Fort Benjamin Harrison State Park, and newer housing under $500,000. It's building its own identity with McCord Square, but it's changing fast, what you see in photos may not match day-to-day living.
All five towns offer better value than the northern suburbs like Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville, and Westfield. But they are not interchangeable. Danville and New Palestine are both 25 minutes from downtown, but they feel nothing alike. Bargersville still functions like its own town; Greenwood is a full commercial corridor. McCordsville offers a smaller high school; Fishers high schools are more than twice the size. These distinctions matter when you're making a decision from 1,000 miles away.
Conclusion
That's exactly why we built our Neighborhood Match Quiz. It gives you a few quick questions to answer about your budget, your commute, the home style you want, and amenities and the things that actually matter to you. And then it gives you a real shortlist of the communities around the Indianapolis metro that fit how you want your day-to-day to look, with the reasons why each one fits. I've taken it myself and it matched me right where my family and Ashley live. So I feel pretty good about how accurate it is. Links are on the screen and in the description below. Take it, then comment or send me a message with what town you got. I'd love to know.
If you get that wrong and you burn your only two-day visit touring the wrong four towns, or you buy in a district you never meant to be in, if you want somebody who's actually walked all five of these towns thoroughly to tell you which one fits how you're going to live, then give us a call or text us or email or just reach out any way that you know how. My team and I will help you map it out, and we'll catch you in the next one.
FAQ
How far are these small towns from downtown Indianapolis?
Danville and New Palestine are both about 25 minutes from downtown Indianapolis, though in opposite directions, Danville to the west and New Palestine to the east. Fortville is about 30 minutes northeast. Bargersville is about 40 minutes southwest. McCordsville sits on the northeast side and shares a border with Indianapolis itself, so it's closer than you might think.
Are these towns more affordable than Carmel and Fishers?
Yes. All five towns offer better value than the northern suburbs like Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville, and Westfield. Your dollar goes further in Danville, Bargersville, and New Palestine especially. McCordsville can get you into newer housing under $500,000, and even under $400,000 in some cases, for homes that are still relatively new.
How do the school districts work in these towns?
Danville is served by Danville Community School Corporation, a single small district. New Palestine has New Palestine Community Schools, also genuinely small. McCordsville is generally served by Mount Vernon Schools, with a high school around 1,500 students compared to Fishers high schools at 3,400 each. Bargersville is the tricky one, you can have a Bargersville address and be in Center Grove Schools or Franklin Community Schools, so you must check address by address.
Which town is best for remote workers?
Danville is a strong pick for remote workers because you get land and space without driving an hour out, and you're still close to I-70 and I-74. You're also only 20 minutes from the airport. Bargersville and New Palestine also work well if you don't need to commute daily and want more space for your budget.
What's the difference between Bargersville and Greenwood?
Bargersville still functions like its own town with its own pace, even as new rooftops go up around it. Greenwood has grown into a full commercial corridor with every big box store you can find across the country, and that comes with congestion and traffic. They're only 10 minutes apart, but they feel very different once you drive both back to back.
Why don't these towns show up in relocation research?
Because they don't rank on the big relocation sites or show up on the first page of Google. When you're moving here from out of state, you're mostly seeing the same five suburbs over and over. But these five towns come up in almost every relocation conversation my team and I have, because they offer what a lot of people are actually looking for, small town charm, better value, and a real sense of place, without the marketing budget of the bigger suburbs.
jason compton
A former teacher turned full-time real estate agent serving Greater Indianapolis. I help buyers, sellers, and relocation clients make informed moves—especially those coming from out of state. From neighborhood insights to home tours, my goal is to simplify the process and help you feel confident in every step.
Stay Informed
Insights, Tips & Life in Indianapolis
Your go-to resource for all things real estate and Indy living. Whether you're buying, selling, relocating, or just curious about the local market, our blog is packed with helpful articles, expert advice, and community highlights to keep you informed and inspired.













