Table of Contents
- Introduction
- Whitestown: An Emerging Suburb Near Indianapolis
- Westfield: A Growing Hub for Sports and Family Life
- Brownsburg: Affordable and Family-Friendly Living Near Indianapolis
- Plainfield: A Suburb for Jobs, Trails, and Affordable Housing
- McCordsville: Fast-Growing Community Close to Indianapolis
- Fortville: Small-Town Charm with Room to Grow
- Noblesville: Upscale Suburb with Plenty of Room for Growth
- Bargersville: Luxury Living Without the North-Side Price Tag
- Buying, Selling, and Investing: How to Act Now
- FAQs
- Final Thoughts
Introduction
If you are moving to Indianapolis and want more house, better value, and major upside, look beyond the obvious suburbs. Rapid job growth, master planned communities, and billions in retail and infrastructure investment are quietly reshaping several pockets around the metro. Right now, many of these markets still show stagnant prices, which means an early move can lock in affordability before demand catches up.
Whitestown: An Emerging Suburb Near Indianapolis
Whitestown has been one of the fastest growing towns in the metro. Since 2010 the population has more than doubled. The combination of interstate access and aggressive city planning is why developers and home buyers are flocking here.
Why Whitestown matters
- Proximity to I-65 gives easy access to downtown Indianapolis and projects north toward Lebanon.
- Major distribution and commercial employers are building facilities in the area, providing local jobs and demand for housing.
- Strategic municipal investment in roads, retail, and community amenities to support rapid residential growth.
The current median home price sits around $330,000, which is still competitive compared with pricier north-side suburbs. That combination of affordability and momentum makes Whitestown particularly attractive for first-time buyers and investors looking to catch growth early.
VIEW HOMES FOR SALE IN WHITESTOWN, IN
Westfield: A Growing Hub for Sports and Family Life
Westfield’s profile is built around Grand Park, a 400-plus acre sports complex that has attracted more than 40 million visitors since 2017. Sports tourism translates into hotels, restaurants, retail, and a steady stream of visitors who boost local commerce.
What to expect in Westfield
- Top rated schools and lots of new construction make it a magnet for families.
- Redevelopment of downtown and infrastructure upgrades are keeping the town ahead of growth.
- Median home price is roughly $385,000, making it more affordable than the top-tier suburbs while offering many of the same lifestyle benefits.
Buyers priced out of Carmel often find more home and modern communities in Westfield. For retirees, newer low-maintenance neighborhoods and strong safety ratings are also major draws.
VIEW HOMES FOR SALE IN WESTFIELD, IN
Brownsburg: Affordable and Family-Friendly Living Near Indianapolis
Brownsburg combines affordability, quality schools, and a strong park system to create a steady, family-friendly market. At around 35,000 residents, it’s big enough to have amenities but small enough to feel community-driven.
Market features
- Easy connectivity via Ronald Reagan Parkway to I-74 and the airport.
- Access to major hospital systems including IU Health West and Hendricks regional facilities.
- Median home price near $310,000 with high owner occupancy rates, signaling stability.
Brownsburg attracts both first-time buyers and move-up families who want larger homes with quality schools. Its steady growth pattern means it’s less volatile and a solid long-term buy when moving to Indianapolis.
VIEW HOMES FOR SALE IN BROWNSBURG, IN
Plainfield: A Suburb for Jobs, Trails, and Affordable Housing
Plainfield sits strategically near the Indianapolis International Airport and I-70. Its logistics-friendly location has lured Amazon, FedEx, Walmart and other employers. Meanwhile the downtown revitalization and an extensive trail network give Plainfield surprising livability.
Why Plainfield works
- A balance of jobs, affordable housing, and focused downtown revitalization.
- Highly connected trail system that makes neighborhoods walkable and family-friendly.
- Median home sale price around $295,000, making it one of the more affordable growth options.
Plainfield is especially suited for families who value outdoor amenities and anyone who commutes to airport-area jobs. It’s also a sensible pick for investors targeting workforce rentals near distribution hubs.
VIEW HOMES FOR SALE IN PLAINFIELD, IN
McCordsville: Fast-Growing Community Close to Indianapolis
McCordsville is often overlooked because it hugs the border of Indianapolis and Fishers, but it has been one of the fastest growing northeast suburbs. The town has doubled its population since 2010 and has a comprehensive growth plan to manage the next decade.
Key pulls
- New developments and upscale neighborhoods attractive to buyers seeking value outside Fishers.
- Community focal points like McCord Square are planned to add amenities and maintain a small-town feel.
- Median home prices around $310,000 with room to appreciate as demand grows.
If you want new construction and access to Fishers without the Fishers price tag, McCordsville is a strong consideration when moving to Indianapolis.
VIEW HOMES FOR SALE IN MCCORDSVILLE, IN
Fortville: Small-Town Charm with Room to Grow
Fortville is a classic small-town resurgence story. Historic downtown charm, boutique shops, and local restaurants now sit alongside planned walkability and green-space investments. Thirty years ago it was quiet; today it is being shaped into a desirable community with room to expand eastward.
Fortville highlights
- Median home price around $285,000, closer to the ground floor for growth.
- Infrastructure upgrades and mixed-use zoning designed to handle rising traffic and new developments.
- Appeals to buyers who want small-town character with easy access to Fishers and Indianapolis.
Fortville is ideal for remote workers and families who want charm and affordability, plus long-term upside as surrounding suburbs expand.
VIEW HOMES FOR SALE IN FORTVILLE, IN
Noblesville: Upscale Suburb with Plenty of Room for Growth
Noblesville sits in Hamilton County, the fastest growing and wealthiest county in the metro. With more than 80,000 residents, Noblesville blends large-city amenities with planned luxury development happening on the east side.
The Noblesville advantage
- Hamilton Town Center and an active downtown create retail and recreation options.
- Median home price around $410,000, reflecting both established neighborhoods and newer upscale development.
- Room to grow. Noblesville could reach and surpass 100,000 residents, which will tighten inventory over time and support price appreciation.
Buyers who want upscale new builds without Carmel or Zionsville price tags should watch Noblesville’s eastern expansion. For those moving to Indianapolis seeking long-term value in a larger suburban city, Noblesville is in the next wave.
VIEW HOMES FOR SALE IN NOBLESVILLE, IN
Bargersville: Luxury Living Without the North-Side Price Tag
Bargersville is rapidly emerging as a south-side luxury alternative. Developers are building higher-end communities with national builders offering modern finishes and maintenance-conscious designs. At the same time the town retains rural charm in places like Old Town Bargersville.
What Bargersville offers
- Median home prices around $440,000 with luxury-level construction and modern amenities.
- Center Grove schools and planned downtown investments make the town attractive to families seeking strong school districts.
- Infrastructure and mixed-use zoning projects aim to manage fast growth while creating a destination community.
Bargersville is for move-up buyers and professionals who want modern, upscale homes without paying premium north-side prices. It is carving out its own identity as a high-demand suburb rather than a simple alternative to Carmel or Zionsville.
Buying, Selling, and Investing: How to Act Now
Here is the practical bottom line for anyone moving to Indianapolis or already living in the region:
- Buyers: Getting into these markets while prices are still reasonable locks in upside as each town fills in, adds retail, and improves infrastructure.
- Sellers: Consider timing your sale strategically. As more people discover these suburbs, listings could flood the market. Staging and targeted marketing will matter.
- Investors: Suburbs with growing job bases and limited rental inventory are prime targets. Look for areas close to new distribution centers, hospital expansions, or major road upgrades.
Decisions become simpler when you match lifestyle needs with market signals. Families chasing top-rated schools, remote workers wanting small-town feel, retirees seeking low-maintenance neighborhoods, and investors hunting velocity-driven appreciation all have clear targets among the eight suburbs listed above.
FAQs
Which suburbs should I prioritize if I am moving to Indianapolis with school-age children?
Prioritize suburbs with strong school systems and family amenities such as Westfield, Brownsburg, Noblesville, and Bargersville. These towns combine top-rated schools, new construction options, and parks or recreation programs that matter for families.
Are these suburbs more affordable than Carmel and Fishers?
Many of the eight suburbs currently offer better affordability compared with Carmel and Fishers, especially for first-time and move-up buyers. Whitestown, Plainfield, McCordsville, Fortville, and Brownsburg often provide more house for the same price in comparison.
Which suburbs are best for investors focused on rental income?
Plainfield, Whitestown, and areas near distribution hubs are attractive for investors because of strong rental demand tied to local jobs. Fortville and McCordsville also have limited rental inventory and rising demand as they mature.
How fast should I act if I am moving to Indianapolis and want to buy in one of these towns?
Act sooner rather than later. Several towns are in early-to-mid stages of growth and stabilized pricing will come as inventory tightens. That said, evaluating neighborhood-level data and timing within the buying cycle is essential for a smart purchase.
What are the common red flags to watch for when buying in a rapidly growing suburb?
Watch for poor infrastructure planning, limited school capacity, overreliance on a single employer, and homes in flood-prone or farmland-to-subdivision conversions without proper municipal support. Look for clear municipal growth plans and active investment in roads, schools, and utilities.
Can I find new construction and affordable options at the same time?
Yes. Suburbs like Whitestown, Westfield, McCordsville, and Plainfield still have a mix of new construction that offers relative affordability compared to premium markets. The key is to move before demand pushes pricing higher.
Final Thoughts
When moving to Indianapolis, the obvious suburbs may feel tempting, but the most meaningful opportunity right now lies in towns that are planning for growth rather than reacting to it. These eight suburbs each have different flavors—some prioritize luxury, some preserve small-town charm, some are logistics hubs—but all share one thing: momentum.
Choosing the right suburb depends on priorities: schools, commute, lifestyle, resale potential, or rental yield. The best strategy is to pair local market data with clear personal goals so you capture upside without sacrificing fit.
If you are moving to Indianapolis and want help evaluating specific neighborhoods or understanding how a suburb will evolve over the next two to five years, use local market insight and planning documents as a guide. Early positioning and informed decisions are what separate buyers who catch the wave from those who chase it later. If you need to buy a home, contact me anytime — call or text 317-932-8620.
READ MORE: Why the Ultra Wealthy are Flocking to Indianapolis
